Welcome to Arrest Stories. A thirty-six-year-old man faces multiple felony charges in Crawford County, Ohio after authorities say he knowingly dealt with a stolen trailer. Here's what may have happened.
Robert Reynolds found himself in custody this August on charges of felony theft, dealing in stolen property, and concealing evidence. The Crawford County Sheriff's Office published his mugshot as part of their standard booking procedures following his arrest.
According to police reports, the case centers around a missing black enclosed trailer. Two former employees reportedly gave Reynolds the trailer to settle a twenty-four hundred dollar debt they owed him. These individuals were described as living in a cow pasture at the time of the transaction.
Reynolds later stated he became suspicious about the trailer's origins and conducted his own research to verify whether it had been stolen. During his investigation, he confirmed his suspicions that the trailer was indeed stolen property.
The case took an unusual turn earlier this month when Reynolds appeared on the Matthew Cox Inside True Crime Podcast to publicly defend himself against the charges. However, law enforcement officials viewed his podcast appearance differently than Reynolds may have intended.
One official stated, "He literally confessed to committing the crimes" during his podcast interview. Another remarked, "So guess who's back? Robert Reynolds," suggesting this may not be his first encounter with law enforcement.
Reynolds had indicated early doubts about his former employees' ability to legitimately acquire the trailer, saying, "In the beginning, I knew they didn't have the means to get it right."
The Crawford County Sheriff's Office emphasized in their statement that "The publication of an individual's mugshot is a factor of charges brought against the individual and is not an indicator of innocence or guilt."
Reynolds now faces the felony charges as the case moves through the court system in Crawford County.
All suspects presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Do not take this report as factual, always verify facts. Thanks for watching Arrest Stories.